If you’re asking why are my emails not getting opened, check something more boring first, before touching a single word of your copy: whether your emails are actually reaching the inbox at all. A brilliantly written email that lands in spam gets the exact same open rate as a terrible one. Zero.
Check deliverability before you blame the writing
Poor sender reputation, missing authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), or a domain that’s been flagged can tank your open rate regardless of how good the content is. If your open rates are consistently low across every single email, not just one campaign, this is where to look first, not the subject line.
Once deliverability is confirmed fine, then it’s worth looking at the actual content.
Where the drop-off usually happens after that
The subject line is doing too much generic work. “Newsletter #12” or “This week’s update” gives someone no reason to open it over the fifty other things in their inbox. A subject line that names a specific, relevant problem earns the open. Vague ones don’t.
The email doesn’t match what the subject line promised. If someone opens expecting one thing and gets a different pitch entirely, they learn to stop opening your emails, and that damage compounds over time.
There’s no clear single action. An email with six links and three different things to think about gets a fraction of the clicks that one email with one clear next step gets. More options rarely means more clicks. Usually it means fewer.
The audience itself might be the issue
If you’ve built your list through the raw, unfiltered tactics that get quick sign-ups but low genuine interest, low engagement isn’t a copywriting problem. It’s a list quality problem. No subject line fixes an audience that never wanted to be there in the first place.
What to check, in order
- Is deliverability actually fine? Check your sender reputation and authentication before anything else.
- Does your subject line name something specific, not something generic?
- Does the email deliver on exactly what the subject line promised?
- Is there one clear action, not several competing ones?
- Is this a genuinely engaged list, or a padded one that was never that interested to begin with?
Not sure if it’s you or your system?
If you want a quick, expert look at what’s actually going on with your emails, book a Shelly, Can You Just…? Hour (£247). We’ll go through it together and pinpoint where the drop-off is happening.
If it turns out to be deliverability itself, System Setup (£2,497) covers the full platform architecture, including DKIM and deliverability setup done properly from the ground up. Email shelly@shellyshulman.com to find out more.
Structure First. Growth Follows.
